MasonLaw, PC | NC Elder & Special Needs Law Attorney

  • Elder Law
  • Special Needs Law
  • Hot Topics & Info
    • 2018 Medicare Premiums, Coinsurance and Deductibles
    • 2019 Medicare Premiums, Coinsurance and Deductibles
    • 2018-19 NC Medicaid and Special Assistance Rates
    • 2019 Veteran (VA) Benefit Rates
    • NC Nursing Home Medicaid Law Explained
    • 2018 Federal Benefit Rate – Federal Poverty Level
  • About
    • Find Us – Charlotte or Asheboro
    • Who to Call
    • Bob Mason, Attorney
    • Ann Mason, Administrator
    • News / Press
  • Client Portal
You are here: Home / General / How To Quickly Appeal A Nursing Home Medicare Denial

February 15, 2013 by bob mason 2 Comments

How To Quickly Appeal A Nursing Home Medicare Denial

Ward is failing to progress?

June and Ward Cleaver’s Saga Continues. A Recap: Mossy Mountain Health and Rehab recently telephoned Mrs. Cleaver and told her that husband Ward was no longer making progress in his rehab therapy and Medicare would no longer pay for services. Ward had been admitted to Mossy Mountain after having suffered a stroke. Because Ward has a host of other health issues, Mossy Mountain is moving Ward to a general skilled nursing services bed . . . but Mossy Mountain told Mrs. Cleaver she needs to get them a check by Friday.

In another article, I discussed why Ward likely does continue to qualify for Medicare nursing home payments . . . at least until his 100 days are used.

What can Mrs. Cleaver do?

Advance Beneficiary Notice Requirements

Mrs. Cleaver did not receive valid notice that could result in the proper termination of services. [NOTE: Dear readers . . . I am putting some legal citations in here for the benefit of my lawyer and nursing home readers. Sorry!] Pursuant to Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS – the federal outfit that runs Medicare) regulation, “[b]efore any termination of services, the provider of the service must deliver valid written notice to the beneficiary of the provider’s decision to terminate services.” 42 CFR § 405.1200(b) (my emphasis). To be sufficient, the notice must be both valid and written. A telephone conversation with a patient’s representative is neither written nor valid.

To be valid, a written notice must be provided “no later than 2 days before the proposed end of the services.” 42 CFR § 1200(b)(1). Clearly, if Mossy Mountain things Medicare benefits ought to be terminated, they need to give Mrs. Cleaver written notice at least two days before the proposed cutoff date. What happens if there is no valid written notice?

The nursing home pays, that’s what. Regulations specify that “[a] provider is financially liable for continued service until 2 days after the beneficiary receives valid notice as provided under paragraph (b)(3) . . . .” 42 CFR § 405.1200(b)(5). Regulations further specify that valid delivery occurs only as of the date of receipt of a valid notice acknowledged in writing by beneficiary on the face of the notice. 42 CFR § 405.1200(b)(3).

Why is valid written notice so important? Because, to be valid, the notice must explain why the nursing home believes Medicare payment is no longer warranted, when an appeal must be lodged, where an appeal must be lodged, and what the appeal rights are.

Remember, notice must contain all the information necessary to make it valid, and it must be delivered at least two days before the proposed Medicare cutoff. Without meeting those requirements, the nursing home is on the hook.

What if Mrs. Cleaver believes Ward should be entitled to Medicare (because he still needs skilled nursing services, or maybe he needs rehab in order to prevent a decline . . . read on below)? How does she appeal?

How to Make an Expedited Appeal

Had Mrs. Cleaver received a valid written notice of proposed Medicare nursing home discharge, it would have told her that she had until noon the day following her receipt of the notice to lodge an expedited appeal of Medicare termination. 42 CFR § 405.1202(b)(1). She could fax, or even telephone her appeal, to the number shown on the notice. The appeal is given to something called a Quality Improvement Organization or “QIO” which is an independent contractor staffed with medical and other personnel. In North Carolina the QIO is Carolinas Center for Medical Excellence in Raleigh; in Georgia it is Alliant GMCF in Atlanta. Mrs. Cleaver could submit additional information (if she had time for her regular family physician to submit an additional opinion, it would be very helpful).

The QIO should render a decision within 72 hours. During the pendency of the appeal, the nursing home cannot bill Mrs. Cleaver. 42 CFR § 405.1202(g). The QIO will telephone Mrs. Cleaver with its decision, and follow that up with a written decision letter a few days later.

What if Mrs. Cleaver disagrees with the QIO?

Mrs. Cleaver can appeal the proposed Medicare nursing home discharge to the Qualified Independent Contractor or “QIC” having oversight authority with respect to QIO decisions. The QIC for the eastern US (which includes both Georgia and North Carolina) is Maximus Federal Services based in Pittsford, New York

If Mrs. Cleaver wants to take it to the next step (which I advise if you sincerely believe you are correct . . . this next step is extremely easy . . . so why not?) she has until noon the day after she receives the initial notification from the QIO (and, yes, that includes by telephone!) to call in or fax an appeal to the QIC. 42 CFR § 405.1204.

Be careful! If the QIO in Raleigh or Atlanta calls and says, “We agree with Mossy Mountain, Mr. Cleaver is not entitled to Medicare coverage. We’ll send you a letter in a day or two” you have until noon the following day to request QIC reconsideration.

The QIC will take a fresh look at the file and consider any other information you have (perhaps another doctor looked at Ward in the last day or two). The QIC will notify all parties within 72 hours of its decision (usually by telephone, followed up by a letter).

What if Mrs. Cleaver Disagrees with the QIC?

The QIC decision will describe what further steps may be taken. At this point, things begin to slow down, and Mrs. Cleaver is no “on the hook” for payments to Mossy Mountain, unless Ward can qualify for Medicaid. There is still some hope.

The next appeal level is to an administrative law judge (ALJ).

The Bad News: These appeals take much longer and Mrs. Cleaver should probably hire an attorney to handle the appeal at this level (if she hasn’t already been working with an attorney). The hearing before a federal ALJ is usually handled via a video hookup. The Good News: The chances of success increase dramatically at the ALJ level because the judge will look more carefully at the law and facts. More Good News: If Mrs. Cleaver wins, she should receive a reimbursement of all that she had to pay Mossy Mountain while Ward would have been eligible for Medicare had they not made the incorrect decision.

Print Friendly

Filed Under: General, Medicare, Nursing Homes Tagged With: discharge appeal, Georgia, Medicare, Medicare appeals, north carolina, nursing home discharge

Comments

  1. Amos Mills says

    February 15, 2013 at 5:23 PM

    Mr. Mason. Thank God for Advocates (like you) for elderly people who are being kicked out of nursing homes unjustly and who families are unable to afford the rising costs of Medical care. With unemployment benefits being cut for those that are unemployed in North Carolina and Medicare not being extended to those who do not have any other health insurance, I salute you and your law firm for providing this information on a pro bono basis to the public. Everyone will transcend this world in the future. A majority of us will need some type of nursing home care if we live long enough, and our families will have to bear the high costs of nursing care

    Reply
  2. Sam Solo says

    November 20, 2017 at 8:15 PM

    Thanks for explaining the need for both a valid and written notice of termination. I can see how this would be important for official purposes considering healthcare has pretty strict healthcare laws. I’ll have to remember this process if I ever have to submit an appeal.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Now Serving Charlotte

704.276.6446

Also the Triad from Asheboro

336.610.6000

Find Us

Get A Free NC Medicaid Nursing Home Rules Booklet

Mason Law Booklet Offer

Great tips from an expert!

Download Now

About Bob Mason

Bob Mason, Elder Law & Special Needs LawRobert A. Mason, JD, CELA, CAP, is owner of Mason Law, PC, of Charlotte and Asheboro, North Carolina, a law firm devoted exclusively to legal issues involving the elderly and the disabled. Read More >>

Browse Articles Here!

Or Search On A Topic

News

Mason Named Chair of NC Board of Legal Specialization

Asheville, NC – July 28, 2017: The North Carolina … [Read More...]

Mason one of two N.C. elder law attorneys named to Super Lawyers

ASHEBORO, NC — Jan. 27, 2017: Elder law and … [Read More...]

Reader Favorites

NORTH CAROLINA SPECIAL ASSISTANCE

NORTH CAROLINA SPECIAL ASSISTANCE

Medicaid in an Assisted Living Facility? Think again! You’ve been looking … [Read More...]

Will Mom Have to File a North Carolina Tax Return?

Will Mom Have to File a North Carolina Tax Return?

CAUTION: This column was written in 2016 and has been updated for 2018. You … [Read More...]

Can You Take a Tax Deduction for Assisted Living Costs?

Can You Take a Tax Deduction for Assisted Living Costs?

Mom is in an assisted living facility.  Mom and Dad both receive Social … [Read More...]

  • Could These Facts Help You Avoid Filing A Federal Tax Return?
  • How Much Can You Earn Without Paying Taxes On Social Security?
  • Tackling the North Carolina Medicaid Application Monster

© 2019 MasonLaw, PC | NC Elder & Special Needs Law Attorney · Rainmaker Platform